The sports trading card industry has recently become a battleground for two major players, Fanatics and Panini. These industry giants have found themselves entangled in a legal battle, each filing lawsuits against the other. Panini kicked off the clash by filing an antitrust lawsuit against Fanatics, accusing them of engaging in “calculated, intentional, anticompetitive conduct” to establish a monopoly in the trading card market. In response, Fanatics countersued, alleging interference with business relations and a breach of duty to negotiate in good faith.
The Dispute Over Licensing Rights
At the heart of the conflict lies the battle for licensing rights for professional sports leagues and their associated trading cards. Currently, Panini holds the licenses to produce trading cards for the NBA and NFL, having secured exclusive rights in 2009 and 2016, respectively. However, Fanatics has managed to secure long-term deals with both leagues and their unions to take over the exclusive rights once Panini’s current deals expire in 2025 and 2026.
Panini’s antitrust suit against Fanatics claims that the latter positioned itself to drive Panini and other potential competitors out of the market while creating entry barriers for their return. Panini further alleges that it was not given the opportunity to bid or compete for the licenses acquired by Fanatics. In response, Fanatics denies engaging in antitrust behavior, asserting that they won the rights due to a superior offer and Panini’s failure to capitalize on their opportunities. Fanatics alleges that Panini engaged in unfair trade practices, strong-arm tactics, and tortious misconduct in an attempt to hinder Fanatics Collectibles’ business.
The Legal Battle Intensifies
The legal battle intensified when David Boies, chairperson of Boies Schiller Flexner and Panini’s legal counsel, issued a statement alleging that Fanatics’ countersuit was a desperate attempt to avoid their serious antitrust liability as outlined in the initial litigation. Boies argued that if Panini had truly been as unsuccessful as Fanatics claims, the latter would not have resorted to exclusive dealing arrangements to block Panini from the market or employ other measures such as cutting off Panini’s supply and raiding its employees.
Fanatics, for its part, declined to comment further on the lawsuits, leaving the legal battle to unfold in the courts.
Fanatics’ Rise to Prominence
Fanatics, originally an e-commerce platform established in 2011, has rapidly expanded its reach to become a dominant player in the sports merchandise industry. The company holds exclusive merchandise rights across various sports leagues, including the NFL, NBA, and even the International Olympic Committee. In 2021, Fanatics made a significant move by partnering with MLB and its players association, acquiring exclusive rights to produce baseball cards. This groundbreaking deal ended Topps’ 70-year relationship with MLB and ultimately led to Fanatics’ acquisition of Topps in January 2022.
In recent years, Fanatics has ventured beyond apparel to tap into the trading card and collectibles market. The company has introduced new features such as adding game-worn jersey patches to rookie cards and launching a live stream shopping experience called “card breaking.” These initiatives aim to enhance the engagement of card collectors and deepen Fanatics’ connection with millions of sports fans.
The trading card segment of Fanatics’ business has attracted significant investment and valuation. In September 2021, the company’s trading card division was valued at a staggering $10.4 billion after a $350 million Series A funding round. This round included investments from prominent firms like Silver Lake, Endeavor Group Holdings, and Insight Partners. Additionally, the NBA and MLB, along with their player unions, hold equity stakes in Fanatics as part of their licensing agreements. Capitalizing on its success, the company raised an additional $700 million in December, bringing its valuation to an impressive $31 billion.
A Legal Clash with Industry-Wide Implications
The legal battle between Fanatics and Panini carries significant implications for the entire trading card industry. The outcome of these lawsuits will determine the future landscape of trading card licensing and competition. It remains to be seen how the courts will weigh the allegations and evidence presented by both parties and what impact this legal clash will have on the multi-billion-dollar trading card market.
As the titans of the trading card industry exchange blows in the courtroom, industry participants and fans alike are watching closely, awaiting the resolution of this high-stakes dispute. Only time will tell the ultimate victor in this legal clash that has sent shockwaves through the world of sports trading cards.
Leave a Reply