In Sunday night’s Super Bowl LVIII loss to the Kansas City Chiefs, the San Francisco 49ers found themselves in uncharted territory. The game reached overtime, and the Niners were not familiar with the new rules implemented by the NFL for postseason overtime. Coach Kyle Shanahan had discussed potential scenarios with the team’s analytics staff before the playoffs began, but many players claimed they were not aware of the overtime setup.
One of the most scrutinized decisions made by Shanahan was to take the ball first after winning the toss. The 49ers managed only a 27-yard field goal, and the Chiefs capitalized on their possession, scoring a touchdown to win the game. Shanahan defended his decision, stating that discussions with the analytics staff had indicated it would be best to take the ball first. The reasoning was that if both teams matched scores on their opening drives, the Niners would get the ball to open the portion of overtime where the first team to score would win.
Shanahan emphasized that his decision-making process was flexible and depended on how the game was playing out. If the game had been more high scoring, he might have chosen to take the ball second to have a clearer understanding of what was needed to win. He trusted the information provided by his staff and felt accurate with the recommendation given the circumstances.
Niners general manager John Lynch shed light on the defensive efforts exerted by the team. The defense had just been on the field trying to fend off Kansas City’s final drive, expending significant effort. Lynch noted that the context of needing time to get fresh played into the decision. Overall, he believed the choices made by Shanahan were sound given the circumstances.
The 49ers returned to the Bay Area after their Super Bowl defeat, and on Tuesday, they cleaned out their lockers and reflected on the plays they wish they had made. The loss on such a big stage will serve as fuel for the team’s motivation to improve and make another run at a championship next season. Shanahan spoke to his players, but he had not yet watched the film from the Super Bowl. He expects his coaching staff to remain largely intact, but detailed conversations will take place in the coming weeks.
As the growing perception that Shanahan can’t win the biggest games continues, the coach remains focused on reaching the NFL mountaintop. Winning a Super Bowl is what matters to him, not changing outside narratives. While the loss was tough, Shanahan understands that success or failure comes down to one game. He hopes to be part of a team that wins the ultimate game at the end of the year.
Shanahan’s decisions in the Super Bowl loss have been analyzed and dissected. The 49ers faced unfamiliar territory and were not fully aware of the overtime rules. Shanahan’s choice to take the ball first has been heavily scrutinized, but he defends it as a result of discussions with his analytics staff. Flexibility and the context of the game were important factors in his decision-making process. Moving forward, the 49ers aim to use the loss as motivation to improve and make another championship run. Shanahan remains unfazed by the perception that he can’t win big games and is focused on achieving the ultimate goal of winning a Super Bowl.
Leave a Reply